Genotoxicity and Cytotoxicity among Pesticide-Exposed Workers: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis


Achmad Ilham Tohari, M.D.1, Muhammad Rijal Fahrudin Hidayat, M.D.1, Nabil Athoillah, M.D.1, Muhammad Yuda Nugraha, M.D.1, Elly Nurus Sakinah, M.D. Ph.D.2, Supangat, M.D., Ph.D.2,*, Saekhol Bakri, M.D., Ph.D.3, Athira Nandakumar, Ph.D.4

1PANAH Research Center, Faculty of Medicine, University of Jember, Jember, Indonesia, 2Department of Pharmacology, Faculty of Medicine, University

of Jember, Jember, Indonesia, 3Department of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, Diponegoro University, Semarang, Indonesia, 4Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Kagoshima University, Kagoshima, Japan.



*Corresponding author: Supangat E-mail: drsupangat@unej.ac.id

Received 30 November 2025 Revised 2 February 2026 Accepted 3 February 2026 ORCID ID: http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4915-9218 https://doi.org/10.33192/smj.v78i3.279093


ABSTRACT

Objective: To provide updated evidence on genotoxicity and cytotoxicity among workers occupationally exposed to pesticides.

Materials and Methods: This systematic review and meta-analysis followed PRISMA guidelines. Studies assessing micronuclei and cytotoxicity biomarkers in occupationally pesticide-exposed workers were included. Pooled analyses used Mantel-Haenszel fixed- and random-effects models, and results were expressed as SMDs with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). The protocol was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42021279189).

Results: Micronucleus frequencies were significantly higher in lymphocytes (SMD 1.59; 95% CI 0.97–2.20; p<0.001; I²=96%) and buccal cells (SMD 1.20; 95% CI 0.67–1.73; p<0.00001; I²=97%) among exposed workers. Binucleated cells were also increased in lymphocytes (SMD 2.51; 95% CI 1.01–4.02; p<0.001; I²=98%) and buccal cells (SMD 0.56; 95% CI 0.04–1.08; p=0.03; I²=96%). No significant difference was observed for CBPI (SMD –0.18; 95% CI –0.90–0.54; p=0.63; I²=96%).

Conclusion: Occupational pesticide exposure is associated with increased micronucleus and binucleated cell frequencies, although high heterogeneity and potential confounding factors limit certainty. No significant association was found for CBPI. Subgroup analyses showed no sex-related differences, while concurrent smoking appeared to amplify genotoxic markers. The available evidence supports a protective effect of appropriate personal protective equipment against pesticide-induced genotoxicity.

Keywords: Carcinogens; farmers; micronucleus tests; pesticide (Siriraj Med J 2026;78(3):240-255)


INTRODUCTION

Food insecurity and undernutrition continue to be major issues in many nations even after numerous steps have been taken to reduce the global hunger crisis.1 As such, the agricultural sector is crucial to increase food availability and achieving food security.2 Additionally, as a result of increasing food demand and decreasing crop production, pesticides are often used in agricultural fields to eradicate various insects, pests, weeds, and other unwanted vegetation in exchange for high productivity.3 There are many different types of pesticides, such as nematicides, herbicides, insecticides, fungicides, and rodenticides. Around two million pesticides are used in the world, of which 47.5%, 29.5%, 17.5%, and 5.5% are related to herbicides, insecticides, fungicides, and other pesticides, respectively.4

Agricultural workers are the population that is continuously exposed to many kinds of pesticides. There are four main routes of pesticide exposure, including inhalation, dermal contact, food ingestion, and an environment that is contaminated with pesticides.5 Pesticides may accumulate within the body and cause many health risks, such as acute poisoning and chronic effects that may lead to genotoxicity, which is the precursor of carcinogenesis.6 The AGRICOH consortium published two studies that examined the relationship between pesticide exposure and cancer incidence.7,8 Compared to the general population, a study by Togawa reported the incidence of primary

cancer diagnosis and specific subtypes in occupational agricultural cohorts. They discovered that women were at higher risk for skin melanoma (meta-SIR = 1.18, CI: 1.01-1.38), multiple myeloma (meta-SIR = 1.27, CI: 1.04-1.54), and prostate cancer (meta-SIR = 1.06, CI: 1.01-1.12).8 In Leon et al.’s study, which focused on non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, researchers found that there was a higher risk of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma among those who had ever used terbufos (meta-HR

= 1.18, CI: 1.00-1.39), chronic lymphocytic leukemia/ small lymphocytic lymphoma among those who had ever used deltamethrin (meta-HR = 1.48, CI: 1.06-2.07), and diffuse large B-cell lymphoma in those who had ever used glyphosate (meta-HR =1.36, CI: 1.00-1.85).7 Several carcinogenesis mechanisms have also been used to demonstrate pesticides’ pathways, such as genotoxicity, cytotoxicity, disruption of hormone levels, oxidative stress, inflammation, immune system regulation, and procarcinogen activation.9-11

Amongst all the mechanisms above, genotoxicity and cytotoxicity have been proven as a method for screening for the risk of cancer and monitoring the prognosis.12 In evaluating genotoxicity-cytotoxicity, biomonitoring assessment is considered the best choice because of the ability to measure chromosomal damage from the beginning phase of chemical carcinogenesis.13 There are many kinds of biomonitoring assessments but this study focused on micronuclei, binucleated cells, and Cytokinesis Block

Proliferation Index (CBPI). For analyzing cytogenetic effects, the micronucleus test provides a sensitive and practical approach.14 Micronuclei are small extra nuclei that originate from chromosomal fragments that are excluded from the nucleus. Furthermore, chromosomal breakage during cell division is closely linked with these markers.15 An international cohort study comprising more than 6000 participants globally reported that there was a high risk of cancer in numerous organs (liver, biliary duct, pancreas, lung, stomach, colon-rectum, urogenital) among the medium/high micronuclei subjects. These subjects also had lower cancer-free patients compared to the low micronuclei subjects.16

Binucleated cells are cells that have two nuclei. These markers often arise in various malignancies such as acute myeloid leukemia, angiosarcoma, and malignant mesothelioma.17-19 There are two separate theories on the formation of binucleated cells: “abnormal mitosis” and “cell–cell fusion”.20 The CBPI demonstrates human lymphocytes’ ability to proliferate in the examined experimental settings as well as the capacity of cells to self-repair.21 Micronucleus and binucleated cells biomonitoring assessment can be obtained through peripheral blood lymphocytes (using the Cytokinesis Block Micronuclei Assay (CBMN)) and buccal cells (using Buccal Micronucleus Cytome Assay (BMCyt)).22,23 Meanwhile, CBPI can only be obtained using the CBMN assay.21

Pesticides induce MN, binucleated cells, and reduced CBPI via clastogenic mechanisms, such as ROS-mediated DNA breaks, adduct formation, and topoisomerase inhibition, leading to acentric fragments that form MN.24,25 Aneugenic effects involve tubulin binding, spindle/kinetochore disruption, and interference with kinesin-14, pericentrin, and Aurora Kinase A, causing chromosome loss into MN. Cytokinesis inhibition from ATP depletion, G2/M arrest, and actin/myosin dysregulation yields binucleated cells and lowers CBPI, signaling cytotoxicity.24,26 These molecular pathways directly link exposure to cytogenetic biomarkers for robust genotoxicity assessment.

However, the published studies regarding these biomonitoring assessments and occupational pesticide exposure remain inconclusive. Studies conducted by Moshou et al. showed an increase in micronuclei both in lymphocytes and buccal cells in the pesticide exposure group compared to the control group (lymphocytes: 13,67 ± 6,3197 vs 8,88 ± 3,4783; buccal cells: 12,46 ±

5,1439 vs 8,50 ± 3,0374) while a study by Pastor et al. did not show any significant results (lymphocytes: 12,55

± 8,5028 vs 13,82 ± 10,1877; buccal cells: 1,03 ± 1,359

vs 1,06 ± 1,4595).27,28 In addition, many studies showed

significant results whereas others showed vice versa. Thus, the objective of this systematic review and meta-analysis is to provide the latest evidence of micronucleus and cytotoxicity assessment in the population who are occupationally exposed to pesticides.


MATERIALS AND METHODS

Study protocol and study design

This study used the Preferred Reporting Items of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines29, and pe practiced the PECOS approach (Populations: Workers exposed to pesticide; Exposure: Any kind of pesticide; Comparison: Populations that are not exposed to pesticide; Outcome: CBPI, micronucleus, and binucleated cells in lymphocytes as well as buccal cells. The study design employed observational studies (including cohort and case-control) to gather papers from the PubMed and Scopus databases. The protocol of this study was registered in The International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) on November 7, 2022, with the registered number CRD42022334503. Deviation from protocol was stated in the supplementary file.

Database searching and study selection

We searched the papers using the same keywords for all databases (PubMed and Scopus): (Pesticide OR Pesticides) AND (“micronuclei” OR “micronuclei assay” OR “genotoxicity”). There was no year of publication restriction, although a language restriction to English was applied. All papers from databases were imported to Rayyan.ai to execute the study selection process and remove duplicates. Two investigators (AIT and MRFH) performed a two-step study selection; the first step was title and abstract screening, and the second was full manuscript screening. All study selection was accomplished independently. If a conflict arose between the investigators, the decision was made through discussion with the third investigator (SS). The study selection is up to date until January 2024. We did not perform a manual hand search in this study.

Eligibility criteria

We determined the included studies based on the following inclusion criteria: (1) observational studies such as case-control, cross-sectional, or cohort studies; (2) assessed pesticide exposure and micronucleus, binucleated cells, or CBPI; (3) availability of data on central tendency (mean/median) and dispersion (standard deviation (SD)

/ standard error (SE) / interquartile range (IQR) / 95% confidence interval (CI); (4) If there was more than

one paper with the same populations, the most recent papers having complete data was selected. The exclusion criteria were: (1) published studies in a language other than English; (2) using the same sample as the latest study; (3) incomplete data to measure the effect size.

Risk of bias assessment

After the study selection, we conducted a risk of bias assessment using the Risk of Bias in Non-randomized Studies of Exposures (ROBINS-E) tool.30 There are seven domains in ROBINS-E, including (1) confounding; (2) selection of participants; (3) exposure classification; (4) post-exposure intervention; (5) missing data; (6) outcome measures; and (7) selection of reported outcomes. Each domain was divided into three levels (“low risk of bias”, “medium risk of bias”, and high risk of bias”) based on the ROBINS-E protocols (supplementary file). The study overall was judged to have low risk of bias if all domains had low risk of bias. If any domain had moderate or high risk of bias, the aggregate risk was categorized as moderate or high, respectively.

Data extraction

We extracted and combined the following information from included studies: (1) name of first author; (2) year of publication; (3) sample size; (4) ages of participants; (5) total number of each gender in participants; (6) smoking status; (7) alcohol drinking status; (8) usage of personal protective equipment (PPE); (9) duration of exposure;

(10) study area; (11) type of occupational exposure; (12) types of plants planted by workers; (13) type of pesticide;

(14) effects estimates (mean and standard deviations) of each outcomes. If the available data were SE, the SD data were obtained using the square root of the sample size.31 If the study reported in median (min–max) or median (IQR), we extracted the information in the same way as in the study. When additional information was required, we contacted the original paper’s corresponding author.

Statistical analysis

The data were extracted and described narratively and quantitatively. Meta-analysis was performed in Review Manager (RevMan) V5.4 (The Cochrane Community). Standardized mean differences (SMD) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated as the outcome measures. SMD can be defined as the mean of the exposure group minus the mean of the control group divided by the pooled SD of all groups. If there was a positive SMD, it indicated an increase in outcome measures due to pesticide exposure, and vice versa.31 The heterogeneity test was calculated using the I2 test which reported low

heterogeneity if the I2 <50% and high heterogeneity if I2

≥50%.31 Random effect models were used in this meta-analysis due to high heterogeneity. The significance of the meta-analysis was set at p<0.05. Publication bias was assessed using a funnel plot and Egger’s test if at least 10 studies were included in the analysis. The sensitivity analysis was conducted using leave-one-out analysis by excluding each study one by one to show the effects of each study in the pooled analysis.


RESULTS

Characteristics of the included study

We found 3592 studies from PubMed and Scopus databases, and then we performed duplicate detection and found that 992 studies were detected as duplicates. All duplicate studies were removed. A total of 2557 studies were removed due to being irrelevant studies or not meeting the inclusion criteria. Approximately 43 papers underwent eligibility assessment; some articles were removed for specific reasons, including the absence of comparison (2 studies), language other than English (6 studies), same sample (3 studies), Non-Occupational Exposure (4 studies), and incomplete data (2 studies). Finally, 26 studies were included in the systematic review and meta-analysis. The PRISMA flow chart is presented in Fig 1. All included studies were published between 2000 and 2023. Most of them were single-center studies, except one study that was a multi-center study conducted in four countries in Europe.28 Among the included studies, six were conducted in Brazil, six in Turkey, two in Greece, Pakistan, and Spain, and one each in Poland, Hungary, India, Argentina, Iraq and Chile. Based on the outcome, 14 studies reported MN frequency in lymphocytes, 18 studies reported MN frequency in buccal cells, six studies reported binucleated cells in lymphocytes, 11 studies reported binucleated cells in buccal cells, and eight studies that reported CBPI (Supplementary Table 1).

Risk of bias assessment

We used the ROBINS-E tools to assess the risk of bias among included studies. The risk of bias decisions for each study and domain are shown in Supplementary Fig 1. Overall, the risk of bias in included studies varied from low to high risk. There were two studies graded as high risk of bias32,33; The main reasons were because of high risk of bias in the confounding domain (due to limited confounding data reported) and high risk of bias in outcome measure (due to inconsistent outcome reported); further reasons for the high risk grading can be found in the supplementary file. There was one study that had an overall low risk of bias.34 Other studies included



Fig 1. PRISMA Flow Chart

in the analysis were scored as need concern due to at least one domain in ROBINS-E filled as “need concern” in confounding, measurement, selecting participants, or reporting data.27,28,35-55

Characteristics of participants in included studies

Table 1 shows the characteristics of participants. The range of mean age among the participants was 32.83

- 49.15 years for the exposure group and 26.5 - 47/87 years for the control group. All studies reported the proportion of each gender in the study. However, several studies were conducted on one specific gender. Studies by Ali (2008) and Yslas (2016) were only conducted on female agricultural workers.39,47 Nevertheless, as many as seven studies were conducted on male agricultural workers.27,33,35,37,40,43,46,55 Almost all studies revealed the smoking habits of the participants, except for three studies.32,44,54 Two studies were conducted on all non-smoker participants. Regarding alcohol intake, not all studies reported the exact data. Fifteen of 26 studies did not mention information about alcohol intake. Regarding the usage of PPE, two studies from Europe reported that 80% of workers used adequate PPE including gloves, protective clothes, masks, goggles, and boots.28,35 Only four studies did not mention any information about

PPE.33,36,47,52 Cumulative exposure time in each study varied from one year to more than 29 years.

Type of pesticides used in included studies

A list of participants’ jobs, types of plants, and pesticides is shown in Supplementary Table 2. Most of the included studies recruited agricultural workers as the exposure group, along with office or non-agricultural workers as the control group. The control group may be from the same area or a different area (another city). Regarding the type of plants, many kinds of vegetables and fruits were identified from all studies, despite three studies from Brazil that focused on tobacco.34,44,51 Regarding the type of pesticides, we grouped them as insecticides, herbicides, and fungicides. The three pesticides used most often in the included studies were from the insecticides group: organophosphate (16 studies), pyrethroid (12 studies), and carbamate (11 studies). In the herbicide group, Atrazine and 2,4-D (2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid) were found in three studies. Paraquat, glyphosate, triazine, and cycloxydin were only found in two studies. Any copper derivatives were the most identified fungicides (6 studies), as well as mancozeb and propineb (4 studies). The percentage of pesticides used is also described in Supplementary Table

2. All of the pesticide characteristic data were compiled

Review Article SMJ


TABLE 1. Characteristics of participants in included studies.


No

Study Country

Age n


Exposure mean (SD)


n


Control mean (SD)

Gender Exposure (M/F)


Control (M/F)

Smoking Habit Exposure

(SM/NS/C-Day mean (SD))


Control

(SM/NS/C-Day mean (SD))

Alcohol Exposure


Control

PPE

Exposure

years of exposure Exposure

Mean (SD)

1

Lucero, 200035

64

32.83 (9.12)

50

38.56 (9.69)

All Male

All Male

37/ 27/ 12.54 (8.47)

36/ 14/ 14.7 (8.47)

NM

NM

80% of workers used gloves

9.82 (8.08) years


Spain











and protective clothes


2

Vrhovac, 200236

10

39.52 (6.04)

20

31 (7.71)

7 / 3

12 / 8

6/ 4/ 17 (7)

7/ 13/ 8.43 (1.88)

NM

NM

NM

22.25 years


Croatia












average

3

Pastor, 200328

244

39.34 (9.84)

231

41.91 (9.73)

198 / 46

194 /37

116/ 131/ 18.6 (9.66)

105/ 126/ 17.58 (8.23)

95.24 (24.22)

98.62 (137.40)

80% of workers used PPE

13.92 (9.06) years


Greece, Spain,









g/week

g/week

(gloves, mask. Boots, googles)



Poland, Hungary









mean (SD)

mean (SD)



4

Bhalli, 200637

29

34.17 (2.96)

35

35.20 (3.52)

All Male

All Male

18/ 11/ NM

17/ 18/ NM

NM

NM

All workers did not use

13.48 (3.84) years


Pakistan











appropriate PPE


5

Sailaja, 200638

54

35.1 (5.20)

54

33.4 (5.50)

42 / 12

43 / 11

33/ 21/ NM

31/ 23/ NM

30 drinkers/ 24

33 drinkers/ 21

Lack of PPE used

8.60 (2.50) years


India









non-drinkers

non-drinkers



6

Ergene, 200733

32

36.21 (6.90)

32

34.56 (5.92)

All Male

All Male

16/ 16/ 20.93 (6.38)

16/ 16/ 16.31 (4.94)

NM

NM

NM

34.56 (10.47) years


Turkey













7

Ali, 200839

69

37.55 (12.75)

69

37.52 (13.47)

All Female

All Female

All Non-Smokers

All Non-Smokers

NM

NM

No PPE

10.26 (6.14) years


Pakistan













8

Bortoli, 200940

29

38.8 (12.2)

37

36.90 (11.10)

All Male

All Male

12/ 17/ 21 (12.40)

17/ 20/ 22.9 (11.50)

21 drinkers/ 8

25 drinkers/ 12

9 used / 20 did not use

16.30 (10) years


Brazil









non-drinkers

non-drinkers



9

Martinez -

70

37.18 (14.07)

70

38.75 (14.27)

45 / 25

49 / 21

42/ 28/ NM

49/ 21/ NM

32 drinkers/ 38

19 drinkers/ 51

No PPE

7 years average

valenzuela, 200941







non-drinkers

non-drinkers



Mexico











10 Coskun, 201142 46

42.5 (10.1735) 48

26.50 (7.90)

34 / 12

26 / 22

31/ 15/ NM

10/ 38/ NM

NM

NM

17% of workers used mask

NM

Turkey









and glove


11 Gentile, 201243 20

36.25 (12.25) 10

37 (12.25)

All Male

All Male

5/ 15/ 13 (4.47)

0/ 10/ NA

NM

NM

Workers used several PPE:

9.93 (11.64) years

Argentina











mask, gloves, and googles (25%);












gloves and mask (25%);












gloves only (25%)

12 Da Silva, 201444

30

42.1 (10.15)

30

40.17 (13.02)

17 / 13

15 / 15

NM

NM

NM

NM

33% of workers used complete 29.23 (12.83) years

Brazil











PPE (gloves, mask, glasses, boots).












67 workers used incomplete PPE

13 Tumer, 201545

58

51.5

58

34.5

51 / 7

42 / 16

29/ 29/ NM

23/ 35/ NM

NM

NM

13 (22.4%) of workers used 17.19 (8.26) years

Turkey


(39.8 - 58)a


(22 - 44.30)a







PPE

14 Martinez-

30

37.7 (16.98)

30

35.9 (14.24)

All Male

All Male

10/ 20/ NM

NM

17 alcohol. 13

NM

All pilots used gloves and mask 2 - 6 years

Valenzuela,201646









Non-alcohol



Mexico









drinkers




Tohari et al.




TABLE 1. Characteristics of participants in included studies. (Continue)


No

Study Country

Age n


Exposure mean (SD)


n


Control mean (SD)

Gender Exposure (M/F)


Control (M/F)

Smoking Habit Exposure

(SM/NS/C-Day mean (SD))


Control

(SM/NS/C-Day mean (SD))

Alcohol Exposure


Control

PPE

Exposure

years of exposure Exposure

Mean (SD)

15

Yslas, 201647 Mexico

37

35.5 (12.40)

34

31.9 (10.60)

All Female

All Female

2/ 35/ NM

0/ 34/ NM

2 drinkers. 35 non drinkers

3 drinkers. 31 non drinkers

NM

7.70 (8.70) years

16

Cayir, 201748 Turkey

68

38.01 (10.01)

43

33.23 (7.39)

39 / 29

26 / 17

37/ 17/ 21.45 (10.28)

26/ 17/ 23.69 (5.74)

1.96 (5.86)

L/Months

4.69 (23.7)

L/Months


10% of workers used gloves.


5 - 15 years











mean (SD)

mean (SD)

6% of workers used mask


17

Kahl, 201834

Brazil

40

45.0 (11.38)

40

45.60 (10.75)

19 / 21

19 / 21

All Non-Smokers

All Non-Smokers

NM

NM

32.50% of workers did not use PPE. 25% used gloves. 10% used complete PPE (mask, gloves, boots, hat, googles)

28.30 (13.28) years

18

Cobanoglu, 201949 Turkey

66

38.7 (11.20)

50

36.3 (9.15)

38 / 28

25 / 25

36/ 30/ 21.9 (10.10)

14/ 36/ 10.3 (5.94)

1.95 (5.94)

L/Month mean (SD)

0.80 (2.60)

L/Month mean (SD)

Only few workers used masks and gloves

NM

19

Moshou, 202027 Greece

24

40.2 (2.3)

24

33.70 (2.30)

All Male

All Male

12/ 12/ 32.08 (5.41)

12/ 12/ 22.08 (3.23)

NM

NM

12.50% of workers used masks. 8.30% of workers used masks and gloves

19.79 (2.46) years

20 Quintana, 202150 54

36.09 (1.60)

26

37.62 (3.10)

52 / 2

8 / 2

17/ 37/ NM

3/ 23/ NM

30 alcohol

2 alcohol

87% of workers used PPE

5.36 (0.43) years

Mexico drinkers. 24 non- drinkers. 24 non- (mask and gloves)









alcohol drinkers

alcohol drinkers



21 Landeros, 202252 30 Chile

39.8 (12.7)

30

39.60 (12)

12 / 18

10 / 20

17/ 13/ NM

8/ 22/ NM

NM

NM

NM

9.70 (9.10) years

22 Dalberto, 202251 84 Brazil

39.58 (13.64)

85

39.85 (13.74)

41 / 43

44 / 41

All Non-Smokers

All Non-Smokers

NM

NM

58.13% of workers wear PPE (gloves, mask, clothes)

25.07 (15.72) years

23 Santos, 202253 81

Brazil

49.16 (10.06)

81

47.87 (10.66)

69 / 12

62 / 15

33/ 47/ NM

21/ 56/ NM

49 alcohol

drinkers. 32 non-

51 alcohol

drinkers. 26 non-

39.70% of workers wear PPE

30 (14) years










alcohol drinkers

alcohol drinker


24 Alarcon, 202354 Mexico

42

38.8 (13.6)

46

32.10 (13.20)

37 / 5

23 / 23

NM

NM

NM

NM

90% of workers do not use 15.40 (10.40) years any PPE

25 Lucio, 202355

Brazil

23

46.96 (16.70)

27

40.55 (11.26)

All Male

All Male

3/ 20/ NM

0/ 27/ NM

14 alcohol

drinkers. 9 non-alcohol drinkers

20 alcohol

drinkers. 7 non-alcohol drinkers

43.50% wear mask; 34.80% wear 35.35 (19.59) years

gloves; 34.8% wear boots; 26.1% wear googles; 4.3% wear apron

26 Alhamadany,

202332 Iraq

100

15 – 57b

103

15 – 57b

NM

NM

NM

NM

NM

NM

Few workers wear PPE NM

Abbreviations: NM = Not Mentioned; PPE: Personal Protective Equipment; M = Male; F = Female; SM = Smokers; NS = Non-Smokers; C-day = Cigarette per day; a= data presented in median(IQR); b=data presented in range.


using a questionnaire. In the occupational condition, the exposure was usually mixed with all types of pesticides.

Meta-analysis of Micronucleus, Binucleated Cells, and CBPI

The forest plot of micronucleus frequency, binucleated cells, and CBPI is shown in Fig 2, Fig 3, and Fig 4, respectively. Subgroup analysis based on the region of study was performed. We applied a random effects model for the meta-analysis due to high heterogeneity (I2 > 50%) between the studies. The meta-analysis of micronucleus frequency in lymphocytes and buccal cells is shown in Fig 2. Regarding micronuclei in lymphocytes, a total of 781 participants were included in the exposure group and 701 in the control group. The pooled SMD showed significant increase of micronuclei in lymphocytes within the exposure group compared to the control group [SMD

= 1.59, 95% CI (0.97, 2.20), p = <0.00001, I2 = 96%].

The subgroup analysis revealed that the results were identical in all regions (Latin and South America, Asia,

and Europe). Meta-analysis of micronuclei in buccal cells included 1,127 participants in the exposure group and 1,047 in the control group. The pooled SMD showed a significant increase in micronuclei in buccal cells within the exposure group compared with the control group [SMD = 1.20, 95% CI (0.67, 1.73), p = <0.00001, I2 =

97%]. However, the subgroup analysis in the European region revealed that although the increase in micronuclei was noted, the results were not significant.

Fig 3 reports the meta-analysis of binucleated cells in lymphocytes and buccal cells. A total of 883 participants (461 in the exposure group, and 472 in the control group) were included in the binucleated lymphocytes analysis. Of these, 1,579 participants (815 in the exposure group, 764 in the control group) were included in the binucleated buccal cells analysis. Both of the pooled SMD in lymphocytes and buccal cells showed significant increase of binucleated cells in the exposure group [SMD = 2.51, 95% CI (1.01, 4.02),

p = <0.001, I2 = 98%] and [SMD = 0.56, 95% CI (0.04,

1.08), p = <0.03, I2 = 96%], respectively. Nevertheless,


Fig 2. Meta-analysis of Occupational Pesticide Exposure on Micronucleus Frequency.

(A) Micronucleus frequency in lymphocytes; (B) Micronucleus frequency in buccal cells.

the regional subgroup analysis showed no significant difference in the European region for both analyses, plus the Asian region for the buccal cells. These results should be interpreted carefully since the number of studies included in these regions was limited. Fig 4 shows the meta-analysis regarding the CBPI value. Based on the

trends of included studies, the CBPI is slightly reduced in the exposure group. However, the meta-analysis was not significant, suggesting that pesticide exposure does not significantly reduce the cell proliferation kinetics [SMD = -0.18, 95% CI (-0.90, 0.54), p = 0.63, I2 = 96%].



Fig 4. Meta-analysis of Occupational Pesticide Exposure on CBPI.

Fig 3. Meta-analysis of Occupational Pesticide Exposure on Binucleated Cells. (A) Binucleated cells in lymphocytes; (B) Binucleated cells in buccal cells.

Meta-analysis based on gender in exposure group

TABLE 2 shows the summary of the meta-analysis based on the gender in the exposure group. Three analyses used fixed effect model (micronucleus in buccal cells, binucleated cells in buccal, and CBPI) due to low heterogeneity proven by I2=0%. All of the meta-analysis reported that there were no significant difference between each gender in the exposure group, indicating the effects of pesticide exposure were the same among male and female workers in terms of micronucleus, binucleated cells, and CBPI. The forest plot of gender in the exposure group is shown in Supplementary Fig 2.

Meta-analysis based on smoking status in exposure group

The summary of meta-analysis based on smoking status is shown in Table 3. Regarding the smokers

compared to non-smokers in exposed individuals, there was significant increase of micronucleus and binucleated cells in lymphocytes within the smokers in the pesticide exposure group, [Fixed, SMD = 0.55, 95% CI (0.18, 0.92),

p = 0.004 I2 = 49%] and [Random, SMD = 3.89, 95% CI

(0.45, 7.33), p = 0.03 I2 = 95%] respectively. Meta-analysis on micronucleus in buccal cells and CBPI was not significant. However, the results should be interpreted carefully due to the lack of studies that mentioned biomonitoring assessment among smokers and non-smokers. We did not perform a meta-analysis on binucleated cells in buccal cells because there was only one study that mentioned the data and which showed no significant difference between smokers and non-smokers.53 The forest plot of smoking status in the exposure group is shown in Supplementary Fig 3.


TABLE 2. Summary of meta-analysis based on gender in exposure group.


Analysis

Studies

Male/Female

Results*

Micronucleus in Lymphocytes

5

334 / 109

[Random, SMD = 0.14, 95% CI (-0.37, 0.64), p = 0.60 I2 = 75%]

Micronucleus in Buccal Cells

4

342 / 105

[Fixed, SMD = 0.13, 95% CI (-0.10, 0.36), p = 0.27 I2 = 0%]

Binucleated Cells in Lymphocytes

3

266 / 87

[Random, SMD = -0.32, 95% CI (-0.98, 0.34), p = 0.34 I2 = 82%]

Binucleated Cells in Buccal

3

300 / 93

[Fixed, SMD = 0.18, 95% CI (-0.07, 0.42), p = 0.16 I2 = 0%]

CBPI

2

232 / 75

[Fixed, SMD = 0.10, 95% CI (-0.16, 0.37), p = 0.45 I2 = 0%]

*(male=SMD positive; female=SMD negative)

Abbreviation: CBPI: Cytokinesis Block Proliferation Index


TABLE 3. Summary of meta-analysis based on smoking status in exposure group.


Analysis

Studies

S / NS

Results

Micronucleus in Lymphocytes

4

58 / 67

[Fixed, SMD = 0.55, 95% CI (0.18, 0.92), p = 0.004 I2 = 49%]

Micronucleus in Buccal Cells

3

44 / 80

[Random, SMD = 0.42, 95% CI (-0.87, 1.71), p = 0.53 I2 = 90%]

Binucleated Cells in Lymphocytes

3

32 / 38

[Random, SMD = 3.89, 95% CI (0.45, 7.33), p = 0.03 I2 = 95%]

CBPI

3

32 / 38

[Random, SMD = 0.33, 95% CI (-1.83, 2.48), p = 0.77 I2 = 93%]

Abbreviations: S: Smokers; NS: Non-Smokers; CBPI: Cytokinesis Block Proliferation Index

Publication bias and sensitivity analysis

Egger’s test and funnel plot were performed for micronuclei and buccal binucleated cells (Supplementary Fig 4). The funnel plot for micronuclei both in lymphocytes and buccal cells showed asymmetry along with significant Egger’s test while the analysis in buccal binucleated cells showed vice versa. Leave-one-out analysis was used to perform the sensitivity analysis, removing each study individually to demonstrate how each study affected the pooled SMD and 95% CI data. The resume of the sensitivity analysis is presented in Supplementary Fig 5. There was no significant difference reported in the pooled SMD after the sensitivity analysis, suggesting that all of the analyses were reliable.


DISCUSSION

Biomarkers of genomic instability and genotoxic damage include micronuclei and binucleated cells, which are caused by chromosome alterations or DNA damage. The potential danger is that the damaged cell will continue to divide and disrupt the cell’s physiological or metabolic functions if the genotoxic damage is not repaired naturally by cellular repair mechanisms or if the altered cell is not removed. This kind of damage has been suggested to be one of the primary mechanisms of chronic disorders and carcinogenesis.56 The results of micronucleus in this study suggest a potential increase of micronuclei within the pesticide exposure group with [pooled SMD = 1.59, 95% CI (0.97, 2.20), p = <0.00001,

I2 = 96%] and [pooled SMD = 1.20, 95% CI (0.67, 1.73),

p = <0.00001, I2 = 97%] for lymphocytes and buccal cells, respectively. Regarding the binucleated cells, the pooled SMD may indicate increase of binucleated cells in the pesticide exposure group for lymphocytes and buccal cells with [SMD = 2.51, 95% CI (1.01, 4.02), p = <0.001, I2 =

98%] and [pooled SMD = 0.56, 95% CI (0.04, 1.108), p =

0.03, I2 = 96%], respectively. However, with only limited studies, the power to detect moderators was insufficient, and we cannot rule out unmeasured confounding (e.g., genetic factors, exact exposure levels, and PPE used, due to differences in reporting across studies).

Pesticide as environmental exposure was believed to have the capacity to delay the cell cycle and decrease cell proliferation.57,58 Cell proliferation or the ability of the cells to repair themselves is represented in CBPI value.21 One possible explanation for the cell cycle delay is a long-term low-level exposure that can trigger apoptosis.57 However, our meta-analysis of CBPI suggests the trend is slightly reduced in the exposure group but not significant [SMD = -0.18, 95% CI (-0.90, 0.54), p = 0.63, I2 = 96%].

The meta-analysis may indicate a negative correlation

between pesticide exposure and CBPI values, although this association did not reach statistical significance due to high heterogeneity and small sample size. It is possible that higher exposure levels could lead to reduced CBPI, but further research is needed to confirm this relationship. Humans are currently exposed to a variety of genotoxic substances found in the contaminated environment. According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency, pesticides may be classified as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic for humans.59 Certain pesticides can cause genotoxicity, endocrine and chromosomal changes, as well as mutations and signaling abnormalities in embryonic or somatic cells.60 Globally, acute pesticide poisoning and chronic exposure are a major cause of mortality and morbidity, particularly in developing countries where the regulations for pesticides are not well-developed.61 Thus, to determine the degree of exposure and health risk, biomonitoring assessments have been developed to examine chromosomal or genetic damage resulting from various exposures, such as micronuclei, binucleated

cells, comet assay, and chromosome aberrations.62 Micronucleus assays for pesticide exposure can be

conducted using exfoliated buccal cells as well as peripheral blood cells (lymphocytes, PBL). This assessment may also be helpful in term of diagnosis and prognosis of certain cancer types and other disorders. Currently, micronucleus assays are the most used method for detecting DNA damaging effects brought on by environmental, lifestyle, occupational, and nutritional factors.63 The included studies used Cytokinesis CBMN and BMCyt for lymphocytes and buccal cell samples, respectively. Micronuclei in binucleated cells are scored in the CBMN assay following cytochalasin B (Cyt-B)-mediated cytokinesis blockage. The selective examination of the micronucleus in cells that have undergone one mitosis is possible by the addition of Cyt-B.22 Therefore, CBMN not only assesses micronucleus but also binucleated cells and may calculate CBPI. On the other hand, the micronucleus assessment in buccal cells followed a different procedure. After obtaining the samples, the BMCyt assay was carried out in a series of steps. These included creating a single-cell suspension, preparing the slide via cytocentrifugation, fixation, and staining with Feulgen and Light Green for inspection under bright field and fluorescence microscopy.64

Regarding the type of pesticides, there were many kinds of pesticides used in the included studies which are presented in Supplementary Table 2. Overall, we divided the type of pesticide into insecticide, herbicide, and fungicide. It has to be noted that not all published studies mentioned the chemical names of pesticides used. Some studies just mentioned “mixed pesticides”

or just mentioned the pesticide group. We arranged the pesticides used based on the information in each study. Organophosphate, carbamate, and pyrethroids are the most common pesticides used in the included studies. According to United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) classification, the most frequent carcinogenic classifications are possible/suggestive carcinogenic for the organophosphate group and probably/likely carcinogenic for the carbamate and pyrethroids group.65,66 Numerous carcinogenic chemicals have been shown to cause or are likely to cause malignant transformation; however, there is no widely accepted mechanistic basis for classifying chemical carcinogens other than genotoxicity, due to the diversity of biological processes involved.67

The results of the meta-analysis regarding the female workers in the exposure group revealed no significant difference. Males and females may respond differently to pesticides because of variations in body mass, fat, hormones, and organs.68 Some of the instances of the sex-specific effects are reproductive issues, development of the fetus, and organ-specific functions such as the testes, ovaries, uterus, and breast. A pooled analysis of previous studies revealed a substantial correlation between women in the highest quintiles for DDE content (pesticide residue) and their relative risks for breast cancer.69 A well-conducted research study in the United States examined over 55,000 men who used pesticides. The study discovered a higher risk of prostate cancer among these men, particularly in those with a family history of prostate cancer and in those who used the fumigant methyl bromide.70

Regarding smoking status, it is generally accepted that smoking cigarettes produces high concentrations of reactive oxygen species (ROS), and that ROS-induced oxidative DNA damage has been associated with cancer and cytotoxicity.71,72 According to a study by Kumar, tobacco-specific nitrosamines are strong mutagenic and clastogenic agents that induce chromatid/chromosomal abnormalities which lead to the formation of micronuclei.73 The detrimental effect of smoking on genotoxicity in the general population is widely known.74 Therefore, this study provides another point of view of the smoking effects in agricultural workers who have exposure to pesticides. The results of the sub-analysis based on the smoking status in this study revealed that there was an increase in micronuclei and binucleated cells in lymphocytes within the pesticide exposure group. Therefore, in the smokers group the source of exposure was not only from pesticides but also through cigarette smoking. This combination may cause higher increase in genotoxicity. Given this, we may not recommend being smokers while still exposed to pesticides.

We performed subgroup analysis in the main outcome measured which showed a difference between the Europe, Asia, and Latin-south America regions. Almost all studies reported a significant increment except those from Europe (Fig 2 and Fig 3). The subgroup analysis of the Europe region within micronucleus in buccal, binucleated cells in lymphocytes, and binucleated cells in buccal cells showed no significant difference even though the pooled SMD was increased significantly with subgroup SMD as follows: [SMD = 0.24, 95% CI (-0.20, 0.69), p = 0.29,

I2=77%], [SMD = 0.07, 95% CI (-0.33, 0.47), p = 0.73,

I2=74%], and [SMD = -0.02, 95% CI (-0.21, 0.17), p =

0.82], respectively. Furthermore, in the Asia region, the subgroup analysis of binucleated cells within buccal cells also showed no significant difference [SMD = -0.41, 95% CI (-2.25, 1.43), p = 0.66, I2=98%].

The difference in regional subgroup analysis may be due to pesticide restriction, PPE regulation, and other non-occupational exposure that differs in each region. Donley et al. reported that about 322 million pounds worth of the pesticides used in US agriculture were prohibited in Europe, 26 million pounds were banned in Brazil, and 40 million pounds were prohibited in China.75 These reports indicate that pesticide restriction regulation is stricter in Europe than in other regions, resulting in limited distribution of dangerous pesticides. Another factor is the usage of PPE. In the systematic review, we found that almost all studies of micronuclei reported significant increase in the exposure group. However, two studies from Europe reported no statistically significant results.28,35 These findings arise due to the usage of PPE by around 80% of workers in both studies. It is essential to wear adequate PPE during the exposure time including mask, gloves, goggles, boots, hat, and protective clothes.76 Thus, the usage of inadequate PPE may cause weak protection against pesticide exposure, as reported by a study in Mexico where the PPE usage was around 87% (mask and gloves) but the micronucleus remains significantly increased.50 In agriculture, where the risk of harm is significantly elevated, implementing effective risk mitigation techniques is essential for farmers, and the proper use of PPE is a critical measure. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) requires farms with 11 or more employees to thoroughly evaluate existing hazards, provide appropriate and effective PPE, and implement extensive training on its proper use.77 The necessary PPE varies depending on the specific hazards in the agricultural workplace. Chemical personal protective equipment is crucial when handling pesticides to safeguard against their toxic effects. Referring to the Safety Data Sheet (SDS) is essential for guidance on suitable

attire, ocular protection, and breathing precautions. Suggested PPE may include caps, safety goggles, chemical-resistant gloves, and full-length shirts and trousers, effectively safeguarding agricultural workers from direct exposure to hazardous chemicals. Respiratory dangers in agricultural activities require the use of respirators to prevent inhalation of airborne hazards. Selecting the appropriate respirator is crucial, especially when hazardous substances are aerosolized and present an inhalation hazard to workers.78 In addition, we must consider sources of pesticide exposure beyond occupational exposure. As mentioned before, there are four ways of pesticide exposure, including food ingestion, inhalation, dermal contact, and contaminated environment.5 A study in Brazil reported that the frequency of micronuclei among the control group from the same area showed a slight increase compared to occupationally exposed workers although there was no statistical significance.51 This study may indicate that there is another source of exposure that affects the control group, it may be from food or environment since all of the samples were from the same area. Based on the results of this study, we encourage the government to pay more attention to policies that require workers to use PPE to protect themselves, and to initiate a regular biomonitoring strategy using micronuclei screening to prevent long-term effects of pesticides and the development of cancer. Workers with an increased number of micronuclei or binucleated cells should be advised to wear more PPE and reduce their pesticide exposure.

This study has several limitations. First, the meta-analysis should be interpreted carefully since the total number of studies in each region may be different, confounding factors that may influence the results were different in each study included, we hardly found tobacco chewing status, which may affect micronuclei in buccal cells, among the included studies, and high heterogeneity was reported even though the leave-one-out analysis showed no difference. Moreover, the Healthy Worker Effect may distort this cross-sectional pesticide studies by favoring healthier current employees, perhaps leading to an underestimation of genotoxic risks, such as micronuclei development. Workers most susceptible to pesticides—exhibiting early cytogenetic damage, cytotoxicity, or symptoms—frequently leave the workforce owing to illness, job transition, or disability, resulting in a “survivor” population with diminished biomarker levels.79 Second, several studies have a small sample size included in the analysis. Third, it is difficult to state which pesticide has more influence on micronuclei and cytotoxicity due to

the unavailability of data in published studies. It has to be noted that many factors may influence micronuclei and binucleated assessments such as age, smoking status, use of PPE, exposure time, and residence. Fourth, the funnel plot and Egger’s test in micronucleus suggested there was a publication bias indicating that studies with significant positive results were more likely to be published than studies with negative or not significant results.


CONCLUSION

This systematic review and meta-analysis suggest that pesticide exposure may be associated with elevated frequencies of MN and binucleated cells. Nevertheless, significant heterogeneity and possible confounding variables undermine the reliability of this evidence. No notable correlation was detected for CBPI values. Further analyses indicated no substantial disparities in micronucleus, binucleated cell, or CBPI effects between males and females. Nonetheless, simultaneous smoking seems to raise the frequencies of micronuclei and binucleated cells in exposed individuals. The results indicate that PPE provides protection against genotoxicity generated by pesticides. We urge the government to prioritize legislation mandating the use of PPE for worker safety and to implement a systematic biomonitoring plan that uses MN screening to mitigate the long-term effects of pesticides and the onset of cancer. Workers exhibiting a higher frequency of MN or binucleated cells should be counseled to improve their use of personal protective equipment and minimize pesticide exposure.

Data Availability Statement

All data are available from the corresponding author and can be shared on reasonable request.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We thank Prof. Chihaya Koriyama, M.D. (Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Kagoshima University, Japan) and Ancah Caesarina Novi Marchianti, M.D., Ph.D. (Department of Public Health, University of Jember, Indonesia) who reviewed and gave valuable comments during the preparation of this manuscript.


DECLARATIONS

Grants and Funding Information

This systematic review and meta-analysis did not receive any specific funding.

Conflict of Interests

All authors declared no conflict of interest.

Registration Number of Clinical Trial

Not applicable.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization and methodology, S and AIT ; Formal analysis, AIT, NA, and MRFH ; Visualization, MRFH and SB ; Supervision, ENS, AN, and S. Writing original draft AIT, NA, MRFH, SB, and AN; All authors have read and agreed to the final version of the manuscript.

Use of Artificial Intelligence

The author declares no use of any artificial intelligence

tool.

Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate

Not applicable.

Consent for Publication

Not applicable.

REFERENCES

  1. Sibhatu KT, Qaim M. Rural food security, subsistence agriculture, and seasonality. PLoS One. 2017;12:e0186406.

  2. Viana CM, Freire D, Abrantes P, Rocha J, Pereira P. Agricultural land systems importance for supporting food security and sustainable development goals: A systematic review. Sci Total Environ. 2022;806:150718.

  3. Zhao W, Teng M, Zhang J, Wang K, Zhang J, Xu Y, et al. Insights into the mechanisms of organic pollutant toxicity to earthworms: Advances and perspectives. Environ Pollut. 2022;303:119120.

  4. Sharma A, Kumar V, Shahzad B, Tanveer M, Sidhu GPS, Handa N, et al. Worldwide pesticide usage and its impacts on ecosystem. SN Appl Sci. 2019;1:1446.

  5. Qi S-Y, Xu X-L, Ma W-Z, Deng S-L, Lian Z-X, Yu K. Effects of Organochlorine Pesticide Residues in Maternal Body on Infants. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne) 2022;13:890307.

  6. INCHEM. WHO-JMPR Toxicological Monographs-Pesticide Residues in Food. InchemOrg, 2022. [cited 2024 Feb 11]. Available from: https://inchem.org/pages/jmpr.html

  7. Leon ME, Schinasi LH, Lebailly P, Beane Freeman LE, Nordby K-C, Ferro G, et al. Pesticide use and risk of non-Hodgkin lymphoid malignancies in agricultural cohorts from France, Norway and the USA: a pooled analysis from the AGRICOH consortium. Int J Epidemiol. 2019;48:1519–35.

  8. Togawa K, Leon ME, Lebailly P, Beane Freeman LE, Nordby K-C, Baldi I, et al. Cancer incidence in agricultural workers: Findings from an international consortium of agricultural cohort studies (AGRICOH). Environ Int. 2021;157:106825.

  9. Eastmond D, Balakrishnan S. Hayes’ Handbook of Pesticide Toxicology. 3rd ed. New York: Academic Press; 2010.

  10. Falzone L, Marconi A, Loreto C, Franco S, Spandidos DA, Libra M. Occupational exposure to carcinogens: Benzene, pesticides and fibers (Review). Mol Med Rep. 2016;14:4467–74.

  11. Alavanja MCR, Bonner MR. Occupational pesticide exposures and cancer risk: a review. J Toxicol Environ Health B Crit Rev. 2012;15:238–63.

  12. Fenech M, Holland N, Kirsch-Volders M, Knudsen LE, Wagner K-H, Stopper H, et al. Micronuclei and disease – Report of HUMN project workshop at Rennes 2019 EEMGS conference. Mutat Res Genet Toxicol Environ Mutagen. 2020;850–851:503133.

  13. Hartwig A, Arand M, Epe B, Guth S, Jahnke G, Lampen A, et al. Mode of action-based risk assessment of genotoxic carcinogens. Arch Toxicol. 2020;94:1787–877.

  14. de Souza DV, dos Anjos Rosario B, Takeshita WM, de Barros Viana M, Nagaoka MR, dos Santos JN, et al. Is micronucleus assay in oral exfoliated cells a suitable biomarker for predicting cancer risk in individuals with oral potentially malignant disorders? A systematic review with meta-analysis. Pathol Res Pract. 2022;232:153828.

  15. Fenech M. The in vitro micronucleus technique. Mutat Res. 2000;455(1-2):81–95.

  16. Bonassi S, Znaor A, Ceppi M, Lando C, Chang WP, Holland N, et al. An increased micronucleus frequency in peripheral blood lymphocytes predicts the risk of cancer in humans. Carcinogenesis. 2006;28(3):625–31.

  17. Stoll LM, Duffield AS, Johnson MW, Ali SZ. Acute myeloid leukemia with myelodysplasia-related changes with erythroid differentiation involving pleural fluid: A case report and brief cytopathologic review. Diagn Cytopathol. 2011;39(6):451–4.

  18. Minimo C, Zakowski M, Lin O. Cytologic findings of malignant vascular neoplasms: A study of twenty-four cases. Diagn Cytopathol. 2002;26(6):349–55.

  19. Kimura N, Dota K, Araya Y, Ishidate T, Ishizaka M. Scoring system for differential diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma and reactive mesothelial cells on cytology specimens. Diagn Cytopathol. 2009;37(12):885–90.

  20. Nishimura K, Watanabe S, Hayashida R, Sugishima S, Iwasaka T, Kaku T. Binucleated HeLa cells are formed by cytokinesis failure in starvation and keep the potential of proliferation. Cytotechnology. 2016;68(4):1123–30.

  21. Ruiz-Ruiz B, Arellano-García ME, Radilla-Chávez P, Salas-Vargas DS, Toledano-Magaña Y, Casillas-Figueroa F, et al. Cytokinesis-Block Micronucleus Assay Using Human Lymphocytes as a Sensitive Tool for Cytotoxicity/Genotoxicity Evaluation of AgNPs. ACS Omega. 2020;5(21):12005–15.

  22. Fenech M. Cytokinesis-block micronucleus cytome assay. Nat Protoc. 2007;2(5):1084–104.

  23. Thomas P, Holland N, Bolognesi C, Kirsch-Volders M, Bonassi S, Zeiger E, et al. Buccal micronucleus cytome assay. Nat Protoc. 2009;4(6):825–37.

  24. Yang L, Baumann C, De La Fuente R, Viveiros MM. Mechanisms underlying disruption of oocyte spindle stability by bisphenol compounds. Reproduction. 2020;159(4):383–96.

  25. Cobanoglu H, Cayir A. Assessment of the genotoxic potential of tetrachlorvinphos insecticide by cytokinesis-block micronucleus and sister chromatid exchange assays. Hum Exp Toxicol. 2021;40(12 Suppl):S158–63.

  26. Ozkan D, Yüzbaşıoğlu D, Unal F, Yılmaz S, Aksoy H. Evaluation of the cytogenetic damage induced by the organophosphorous insecticide acephate. Cytotechnology. 2009;59(2):73–80.

  27. Moshou H, Karakitsou A, Yfanti F, Hela D, Vlastos D, Paschalidou AK, et al. Assessment of genetic effects and pesticide exposure of farmers in NW Greece. Environ Res. 2020;186:109558.

  28. Pastor S, Creus A, Parrón T, Cebulska-Wasilewska A, Siffel C, Piperakis S, et al. Biomonitoring of four European populations occupationally exposed to pesticides: use of micronuclei as

    biomarkers. Mutagenesis. 2003;18(3):249–58.

  29. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. J Clin Epidemiol. 2009;62(10):1006–12.

  30. Morgan RL, Thayer KA, Santesso N, Holloway AC, Blain R, Eftim SE, et al. A risk of bias instrument for non-randomized studies of exposures: A users’ guide to its application in the context of GRADE. Environ Int. 2019;122:168–84.

  31. Higgins T, Green S, Thomas J, Chandler J, Cumpston M, Li T, et al. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Wiley; 2011. Available from: https://www.cochrane.org/authors/ handbooks-and-manuals/handbook

  32. Alhamadany AYM, Khalaf SD, Alkateb YNM. Genotoxicity and genomic instability in oral epithelial cells of agricultural workers exposed to pesticides using micronucleus and comet assay in Nineveh, Iraq. Journal of Applied and Natural Science. 2023;15:473–9.

  33. Ergene S, Çelik A, Çavaş T, Kaya F. Genotoxic biomonitoring study of population residing in pesticide contaminated regions in Göksu Delta: Micronucleus, chromosomal aberrations and sister chromatid exchanges. Environ Int. 2007;33(7):877–85.

  34. Kahl VFS, Dhillon V, Fenech M, De Souza MR, Da Silva FN, Marroni NAP, et al. Occupational exposure to pesticides in tobacco fields: The integrated evaluation of nutritional intake and susceptibility on genomic and epigenetic instability. Oxid Med Cell Longev. 2018;2018:7017423.

  35. Lucero L, Pastor S, Suarez S, Durban R, Gomez C, Parron T, et al. Cytogenetic biomonitoring of Spanish greenhouse workers exposed to pesticides: micronuclei analysis in peripheral blood lymphocytes and buccal epithelial cells. Mutation Research. 2000;464(2):255-62.

  36. Garaj-Vrhovac V, Zeljezic D. Assessment of genome damage in a population of Croatian workers employed in pesticide production by chromosomal aberration analysis, micronucleus assay and Comet assay. J Appl Toxicol. 2002;22(4):249–55.

  37. Bhalli JA, Khan QM, Haq MA, Khalid AM, Nasim A. Cytogenetic analysis of Pakistani individuals occupationally exposed to pesticides in a pesticide production industry. Mutagenesis. 2006;21(2):143–8.

  38. Sailaja N, Chandrasekhar M, Rekhadevi PV, Mahboob M, Rahman MF, Vuyyuri SB, et al. Genotoxic evaluation of workers employed in pesticide production. Mutat Res. 2006;609(1):74–80.

  39. Ali T, Bhalli JA, Rana SM, Khan QM. Cytogenetic damage in female pakistani agricultural workers exposed to pesticides. Environ Mol Mutagen. 2008;49(5):374–80.

  40. Bortoli GM de, Azevedo MB de, Silva LB da. Cytogenetic biomonitoring of Brazilian workers exposed to pesticides: Micronucleus analysis in buccal epithelial cells of soybean growers. Mutat Res. 2009;675(1-2):1–4. H

  41. Martínez-Valenzuela C, Gómez-Arroyo S, Villalobos-Pietrini R, Waliszewski S, Calderón-Segura ME, Félix-Gastélum R, et al. Genotoxic biomonitoring of agricultural workers exposed to pesticides in the north of Sinaloa State, Mexico. Environ Int. 2009;35(8):1155–9.

  42. Coskun M, Coskun M, Cayir A, Ozdemir O. Frequencies of micronuclei (MNi), nucleoplasmic bridges (NPBs), and nuclear buds (NBUDs) in farmers exposed to pesticides in Çanakkale, Turkey. Environ Int. 2011;37(1):93–6.

  43. Gentile N, Mañas F, Bosch B, Peralta L, Gorla N, Aiassa D. Micronucleus assay as a biomarker of genotoxicity in the occupational exposure to agrochemicals in rural workers. Bull

    Environ Contam Toxicol. 2012;88(6):816–22.

  44. Da Silva FR, Kvitko K, Rohr P, Abreu MB, Thiesen F V, Da Silva J. Genotoxic assessment in tobacco farmers at different crop times. Sci Total Environ. 2014;490:334–41.

  45. Tumer TB, Savranoglu S, Atmaca P, Terzioglu G, Sen A, Arslan S. Modulatory role of GSTM1 null genotype on the frequency of micronuclei in pesticide-exposed agricultural workers. Toxicol Ind Health. 2015;32(12):1942–51.

  46. Martínez-Valenzuela C, Waliszewski SM, Amador-Muñoz O, Meza E, Calderón-Segura ME, Zenteno E, et al. Aerial pesticide application causes DNA damage in pilots from Sinaloa, Mexico. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2016;24(3):2412–20.

  47. Castañeda-Yslas IJ, Arellano-García ME, García-Zarate MA, Ruíz-Ruíz B, Zavala-Cerna MG, Torres-Bugarín O. Biomonitoring with Micronuclei Test in Buccal Cells of Female Farmers and Children Exposed to Pesticides of Maneadero Agricultural Valley, Baja California, Mexico. J Toxicol. 2016;2016:7934257.

  48. [Çayir A, Coskun M, Coskun M, Cobanoglu H. DNA damage and circulating cell free DNA in greenhouse workers exposed to pesticides. Environ Mol Mutagen. 2018;59(2):161–9.

  49. Cobanoglu H, Coskun M, Coskun M, Çayir A. Results of buccal micronucleus cytome assay in pesticide-exposed and non-exposed group. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2019;26(19):19676–83.

  50. Valencia-Quintana R, López-Durán RM, Milić M, Bonassi S, Ochoa-Ocaña MaA, Uriostegui-Acosta MO, et al. Assessment of Cytogenetic Damage and Cholinesterases’ Activity in Workers Occupationally Exposed to Pesticides in Zamora-Jacona, Michoacan, Mexico. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021; 18(12):6269.

  51. Dalberto D, Alves J, Garcia ALH, de Souza MR, Abella AP, Thiesen F V, et al. Exposure in the tobacco fields: Genetic damage and oxidative stress in tobacco farmers occupationally exposed during harvest and grading seasons. Mutat Res Genet Toxicol Environ Mutagen. 2022;878:503485.

  52. Landeros N, Duk S, Márquez C, Inzunza B, Acuña-Rodríguez IS, Zúñiga-Venegas LA. Genotoxicity and Reproductive Risk in Workers Exposed to Pesticides in Rural Areas of Curicó, Chile: A Pilot Study. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022;19(24):16608.

  53. dos Santos IC, da Silva JT, Rohr P, Lengert A van H, de Lima MA, Kahl VFS, et al. Genomic instability evaluation by BMCyt and telomere length in Brazilian family farmers exposed to pesticides. Mutat Res Genet Toxicol Environ Mutagen. 2022; 878:503479.

  54. Sánchez-Alarcón J, Milić M, Bonassi S, Gómez-Arroyo S, Cortés-Eslava J, Flores-Márquez AR, et al. Occupational exposure to pesticides: DNA damage in horticulturist from Nativitas, Tlaxcala in Mexico. Environ Toxicol Pharmacol. 2023;100:104141.

  55. Lucio FT, Almeida IV, Buzo MG, Vicentini VEP. Genetic instability in farmers using pesticides: A study in Brazil with analysis combining alkaline comet and micronucleus assays. Mutat Res Genet Toxicol Environ Mutagen. 2023;886:503587.

  56. Mostafalou S, Abdollahi M. Pesticides and human chronic diseases: evidences, mechanisms, and perspectives. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 2013;268(2):157–77.

  57. Kirsch-Volders M, Fenech M. Inclusion of micronuclei in non-divided mononuclear lymphocytes and necrosis/apoptosis may provide a more comprehensive cytokinesis block micronucleus assay for biomonitoring purposes. Mutagenesis. 2001;16(1):51–8.

  58. Alwaeli AM, Al-Marayaty SS, Al-Khalisy MH, Assi MH. Morphologic Features and Morphometric Measurements of

    Human Oocytes That Failed to Cleave after Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI). Siriraj Med J. 2026;78(1):1–10.

  59. [USEPA. Chemicals Evaluated for Carcinogenic Potential: Office of Pesticides Programs. 2022. Available from: https:// npic.orst.edu/chemicals_evaluated.pdf

  60. [Sasikala S, Minu Jenifer M, Velavan K, Sakthivel M, Sivasamy R, Fenwick Antony ER. Predicting the relationship between pesticide genotoxicity and breast cancer risk in South Indian womenininvitroandinvivoexperiments. Sci Rep. 2023;13(1):9712.

  61. Boedeker W, Watts M, Clausing P, Marquez E. The global distribution of acute unintentional pesticide poisoning: estimations based on a systematic review. BMC Public Health. 2020;20(1):1875.

  62. Sommer S, Buraczewska I, Kruszewski M. Micronucleus Assay: The Stateof Art, and Future Directions. Int JMol Sci. 2020;21(4):1534.

  63. [Nersesyan A, Kundi M, Fenech M, Stopper H, da Silva J, Bolognesi C, et al. Recommendations and quality criteria for micronucleus studies with humans. Mutat Res Rev Mutat Res. 2022;789:108410.

  64. Thomas P, Holland N, Bolognesi C, Kirsch-Volders M, Bonassi S, Zeiger E, et al. Buccal micronucleus cytome assay. Nat Protoc. 2009;4(6):825–37.

  65. Schwingl PJ, Lunn RM, Mehta SS. A tiered approach to prioritizing registered pesticides for potential cancer hazard evaluations: implications for decision making. Environmental Health 2021; 20(1):13.

  66. USEPA. USEPA Pesticide Chemical Search Database. OrdspubEpaGov, 2023. https://ordspub.epa.gov/ords/pesticides/ f?p=CHEMICALSEARCH:1

  67. Stewart B. Mechanisms of carcinogenesis: from initiation and promotion to hallmarks. Lyon: International Agency for Research on Cancer Scientific Publications; 2019.

  68. D’Archivio M, Coppola L, Masella R, Tammaro A, La Rocca C. Sex and Gender Differences on the Impact of Metabolism-Disrupting Chemicals on Obesity: A Systematic Review. Nutrients. 2024;16(2):181.

  69. [Ledda C, Bracci M, Lovreglio P, Senia P, Larrosa M, Martinez-Jarreta B, et al. Pesticide exposure and gender discrepancy in

    breast cancer. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2021;25(7):2898–915.

  70. Alavanja MCR, Samanic C, Dosemeci M, Lubin J, Tarone R, Lynch CF, et al. Use of agricultural pesticides and prostate cancer risk in the Agricultural Health Study cohort. Am J Epidemiol. 2003;157(9):800–14.

  71. Chen Z, Wang D, Liu X, Pei W, Li J, Cao Y, et al. Oxidative DNA damage is involved in cigarette smoke-induced lung injury in rats. Environ Health Prev Med. 2015;20(5):318–24.

  72. Soi-ampornkul R, Ghimire S, Thangnipon W, Suwanna N, Vatanashevanopakorn C. Curcumin Attenuates Hydrogen Peroxide-Induced Cytotoxicity in Human Neuroblastoma SK-N-SH Cells. Siriraj Med J. 2018;70(3):184–90.

  73. Kumar V, Rao NN, Nair NS. Micronuclei in oral squamous cell carcinoma. A marker of genotoxic damage. Indian J Dent Res. 2000;11(3):101–6.

  74. Simanjuntak AM, Putra MRE, Amalia NP, Hutapea A, Suyanto S, Siregar IE. Lung and Airway Disease Caused by E-Cigarette (Vape): A Systematic Review. Siriraj Med J. 2024;76(5):325–32.

  75. Donley N. The USA lags behind other agricultural nations in banning harmful pesticides. Environ Health. 2019;18(1):44.

  76. FAO, WHO. International Code of Conduct on Pesticide Management: Guidelines on licensing of public health pest control operators. Rome: WHO Press; 2015.

  77. OSHA. Agricultural operations - hazards and controls. Occupational Safety and Health Administration, United States Department of Labor, 2022. [cited 2026 Jan 19]. Available from: https:// www.osha.gov/agricultural-operations/hazards

  78. USDA. Personal Protective Equipments. United States Department of Agriculture Agricultural Research Service, 2016. [cited 2026 Jan 19]. Available from: https://www.ars.usda.gov/northeast-area/ docs/safety-health-and-environmental-training/personal-protective-equipment/

  79. Chowdhury R, Shah D, Payal AR. Healthy Worker Effect Phenomenon: Revisited with Emphasis on Statistical Methods

- A Review. Indian J Occup Environ Med. 2017;21(1):2–8.